| All-Americans |
| 1947 » Andy Phillip, 1B |
| 1947 » Lee Eilbracht, C |
| 1948 » Russ Steger, OF |
| 1951 » Dick Raklovits, 3B |
| 1959 » Bob Klaus, SS |
| 1962 » Tom Fletcher, LHP |
| 1973 » Bob Polock, 2B, (2nd) |
| 1987 » Darrin Fletcher, C (1st) |
| 1988 » Mark Dalesandro, 2B |
|
Baseball America Summer Team (2nd) |
| 1990 » Mark Dalesandro, 2B |
|
ABCA (1st) |
|
Baseball America (2nd) |
| 1991 » Bubba Smith, UT |
|
Collegiate Baseball (3rd) |
| 1991 » Larry Sutton, OF |
|
Collegiate Baseball (3rd) |
| 1993 » Scott Spiezio, IF |
|
Collegiate Baseball (3rd) |
| 1994 » Forry Wells, OF |
|
Smith Super Team/NCBWA (HM) |
| 1994 » Tom Sinak, OF |
|
Smith Super Team/NCBWA (HM) |
| 1996 » Josh Klimek, SS |
|
ABCA (1st) |
|
Baseball America (1st) |
|
Collegiate Baseball (1st) |
|
Smith Super Team (1st) |
| 1996 » Brian McClure, 2B |
|
ABCA (2nd) |
| 1998 » Brett Weber, RHP |
|
NCBWA (2nd) |
|
Collegiate Baseball (3rd) |
|
ABCA (3rd) |
| 1998 » D.J. Svihlik, 2B |
|
NCBWA (2nd) |
| 1999 » Jimmy Journell, RHP |
|
Baseball America (2nd) |
|
NCBWA (2nd) |
| 1999 » D.J. Svihlik, 2B |
|
NCBWA (Honorable Mention) |
| 2000 » Jason Anderson, RHP |
|
ABCA (1st) |
|
Collegiate Baseball (2nd) |
| 2001 » Drew Dickinson, LHP |
|
Collegiate Baseball (3rd) |
| 2002 » Drew Dickinson, LHP |
|
Collegiate Baseball (3rd) |
| 2005 » Drew Davidson, OF |
|
Collegiate Baseball (3rd) |
| 2007 » Lars Davis, C |
|
PING! Baseball (1st) |
|
Collegiate Baseball (2nd) |
|
ABCA (3rd) |
| 2008 » Kyle Hudson, OF |
|
ABCA (3rd) |
| 2009 » Brandon Wikoff, SS |
|
Ping! Baseball (2nd) |
| 2013 » Justin Parr, OF |
|
NCBWA (1st) |
|
Collegiate Baseball (1st) |
|
Baseball America (2nd) |
|
Perfect Game (2nd) |
|
ABCA (2nd) |
|
CollegeBaseballInsider.com (2nd) |
| 2015 » Tyler Jay, LHP |
|
Baseball America (1st) |
|
NCBWA (1st) |
|
ABCA (1st) |
|
Collegiate Baseball (1st) |
|
Perfect Game (1st) |
|
D1Baseball.com (2nd) |
| 2015 » Kevin Duchene, LHP |
|
NCBWA (2nd) |
|
ABCA (2nd) |
|
D1Baseball.com (2nd) |
|
Collegiate Baseball (2nd) |
|
Baseball America (2nd) |
|
Perfect Game (2nd) |
| 2015 » David Kerian, 1B |
|
NCBWA (2nd) |
|
ABCA (2nd) |
|
D1Baseball.com (2nd) |
|
Collegiate Baseball (2nd) |
|
Baseball America (2nd) |
|
Perfect Game (2nd) |
| 2016 » Cody Sedlock, RHP |
|
Baseball America (1st) |
|
D1Baseball.com (2nd) |
|
ABCA (3rd) |
| 2018 » Bren Spillane, 1B |
|
Baseball America (1st) |
|
NCBWA (1st) |
|
ABCA (1st) |
|
Collegiate Baseball (1st, National Player of the Year) |
|
Perfect Game (1st) |
|
D1Baseball.com (1st) |
| 2019 » Garrett Acton, RHP |
|
NCBWA (1st) |
|
Perfect Game (1st) |
|
ABCA (2nd) |
|
Collegiate Baseball (2nd) |
| 2024 » Camden Janik, C |
|
ABCA (3rd) |
| 2024 » Jacob Schroeder, DH |
|
College Baseball Foundation (2nd) |
