| All-Big Ten |
| 1949 |
Herb Plews, 2B (2nd) |
| 1950 |
Russ Steger, OF (1st) |
|
Dick Raklovits, OF (2nd) |
|
Alby Plain, P (2nd) |
| 1951 |
Dick Raklovits, 3B (1st) |
|
Bill Hoffman, C (1st) |
|
George Maier, P (1st) |
| 1953 |
Jerry Miller, 2B (2nd) |
|
Ron Ultes, RF (2nd) |
|
Clive Follmer, P (2nd) |
| 1955 |
Bob Shoptwa, CF (2nd) |
|
Vic Petreshene, 1B (3rd) |
| 1956 |
Ed Linbeck, CF (2nd) |
| 1957 |
Bob Klaus, SS (1st) |
|
Jim Frillman, CF (2nd) |
| 1958 |
Bob Klauss, SS (1st) |
|
Casey Barszcz, 3B (2nd) |
|
Russ Martin, 1B (2nd) |
| 1959 |
Bob Klauss, SS (1st) |
| 1960 |
Ethan Blackaky, OF (2nd) |
|
John Jurasevich, OF (3rd) |
| 1961 |
Doug Mills, P (1st) |
|
Jerry Renner, 1B (2nd) |
|
Francis Felichio, OF (2nd) |
| 1962 |
Lloyd Flodin, C (1st) |
|
Tom Fletcher, P (lst) |
|
Jerry Renner, 1B (3rd) |
|
Tony Eichelberger, SS (2nd) |
|
Doug Mills, P (2nd) |
| 1963 |
Tony Provenzano, OF (1st) |
|
Jerry Weygandt, P (1st) |
|
Jerry Renner, 1B (3rd) |
|
Lloyd Flodin, C (3rd) |
| 1964 |
Jim Vopicka, SS (2nd) |
| 1965 |
Jim Vopicka, SS (2nd) |
|
Dan Humay, 2B (3rd) |
|
Ken Holtzman, P (3rd) |
| 1966 |
Jerry Szukala, 1B (3rd) |
|
Dan Humay, SS (3rd) |
| 1967 |
Mike Murawski, OF (2nd) |
|
Ken Rizzo, C (2nd) |
|
Dan Humay, SS (3rd) |
| 1968 |
Mike Murawski, OF (1st) |
|
Ken Rizzo, C (2nd) |
|
Augie Matejzel, 2B (3rd) |
|
Randy Crews, 3B (3rd) |
| 1969 |
Rich Binder, P (1st) |
|
Clyde Keuha, OF (2nd) |
|
Bob Windmiller, C (2nd) |
|
Augie Matejzel, 2B (3rd) |
| 1970 |
Randy Drews, 1B (1st) |
| 1971 |
Bob Polock, 2B (2nd) |
|
Wes Dixon, OF (2nd) |
|
Larry Swakon, C (2nd) |
| 1972 |
Dave Engle, P (3rd) |
| 1973 |
Bob Polock, 2B (2nd) |
|
Jon Siron, SS (1st) |
|
Ken Ossola, OF (3rd) |
| 1974 |
Doug Kleber, OF (1st) |
|
Al Ryniec, DH (2nd) & OF (3rd) |
| 1975 |
Doug Kleber, OF (2nd) |
|
Ron Lapins, OF (3rd) |
| 1976 |
Dan Ingram, P (2nd) |
|
Pat Fazzini, OF (3rd) |
| 1977 |
Steve Borre, OF (3rd) |
| 1978 |
John Peach, OF (2nd) |
| 1979 |
Paul Marsillo, OF (1st) |
| 1980 |
Paul Marsillo, OF (1st) |
|
Carl DePaolis, C (2nd) |
|
Tim Richardson, 3B (2nd) |
| 1981 |
Brian Bock, DH (1st) |
|
Tim Richardson, 1B (2nd) |
|
Todd Schmitke, OF (2nd) |
|
Jeff Innis, P (2nd) |
|
Brian White, 2B (3rd) |
|
Dave Rear, OF (3rd) |
| 1982 |
Tim Richardson, 1B (1st) |
|
Rick Filipo, P (1st) |
|
Brian White, 2B (2nd) |
|
Rob Pullen, SS (2nd) |
|
Ken Warmbier, DH (2nd) |
|
Todd Schmitke, OF (3rd) |
|
Randy Conte, P (3rd) |
| 1983 |
Gary Borg, OF (2nd) |
| 1984 |
Gary Borg, 1B (3rd) |
| 1985 |
Donn Pall, P (1st) |
|
Gary Borg, OF (2nd) |
|
Tony Michalak, SS (3rd) |
|
Dave Payton, OF (3rd) |
|
Darrin Fletcher, DH (3rd) |
| 1986 |
Brad Wentz, OF (1st) |
|
Darrin Fletcher, 1B (2nd) |
|
Tony Michalak, SS (3rd) |
| 1987 |
Darrin Fletcher, C (1st) |
|
Mike Wolters, 1B (1st) |
|
Dave Payton, 3B (1st) |
|
Tony Michalak, SS (2nd) |
| 1988 |
Mike Munson, P (3rd) |
|
Mike Wolters, OF (3rd) |
| 1989 |
Bubba Smith, 1B (1st) |
|
Don Cuchran, OF (2nd) |
|
Wil Parsons, 2B (3rd) |
| 1990 |
Mark Dalesandro, DH (1st) |
|
Brian Roberts 1B (1st) |
|
Kevin O’Connor, OF (2nd) |
|
Wil Parsons, 2B (2nd) |
| 1991 |
Larry Sutton, OF (2nd) |
|
Sean Mulligan, C (2nd) |
|
Bubba Smith, 1B (3rd) |
| 1992 |
Larry Sutton, OF (1st) |
|
Scott Spiezio, 3B (3rd) |
| 1993 |
Scott Spiezio, 1B (2nd) |
|
Forry Wells, OF (2nd) |
|
Dave Wohlwend, 3B (3rd) |
|
Brian Schullian, C (3rd) |
|
Keith Toriani, P (3rd) |
| 1994 |
Forry Wells, 1B (1st) |
|
Ken Crawford, DH (1st) |
|
Tom Sinak, OF (2nd) |
|
Andy Kortkamp, C (3rd) |
|
Andy Thompson, OF (3rd) |
|
Dave Wohlwend, 3B (3rd) |
| 1995 |
Josh Klimek, SS (1st) |
|
Tom Sinak, OF (1st) |
|
Brian McClure, 2B (2nd) |
|
John Oestreich, P (2nd) |
|
Dusty Rhodes, OF (3rd) |
|
Brett Laurvick, DH (3rd) |
|
Sean Williams, P (3rd) |
| 1996 |
Josh Klimek, SS (1st) |
|
Brian McClure, 2B (1st) |
|
Danny Rhodes, OF (1st) |
|
Brett Weber, P (1st) |
|
Dusty Rhodes, OF (2nd) |
|
Aaron Nieckula, C (3rd) |
|
Brian Hecht, P (3rd) |
| 1997 |
Brian Hecht, P (2nd) |
|
Aaron Nieckula, C (2nd) |
|
Danny Rhodes, OF (2nd) |
|
Dusty Rhodes, OF (3rd) |
| 1998 |
Jimmy Journell, RP (1st) |
|
Craig Marquie, 3B (1st) |
|
Aaron Nieckula, C (1st) |
|
Dan O’Neill, OF (1st) |
|
D.J. Svihlik, 2B (1st) |
|
Brett Weber, P (1st) |
|
Danny Rhodes, OF (2nd) |
|
Dusty Rhodes, OF (2nd) |
|
Kevin Rudden, 1B (3rd) |
|
Cody Salter, P (3rd) |
|
Tom Zidlicky, P (3rd) |
| 1999 |
Jason Anderson, P (1st) |
|
Jimmy Journell, RP (1st) |
|
Jon Anderson, SS (2nd) |
|
Craig Marquie, OF (2nd) |
|
Luke Simmons, DH (2nd) |
|
D.J. Svihlik, 2B (3rd) |
| 2000 |
Jason Anderson, P (1st) |
|
Andy Schutzenhofer, 1B (1st) |
|
Chris Basak, SS (2nd) |
|
Luke Simmons, DH (2nd) |
|
D.J. Svihlik, 2B (2nd) |
|
Matt Vorwald, RP (2nd) |
|
Brady Ballard, OF (3rd) |
|
Craig Marquie, 3B (3rd) |
| 2001 |
Andy Dickinson, P (1st) |
|
Rob Fischer, OF (2nd) |
|
Andy Schutzenhofer, 1B (2nd) |
|
Brady Ballard, OF (3rd) |
|
Luke Simmons, 3B (3rd) |
| 2002 |
Patrick Arlis, C (1st) |
|
Andy Dickinson, P (1st) |
|
Dave Mazurek, RP (2nd) |
|
Andy Schutzenhofer, 1B (2nd) |
|
Drew Davidson, OF (3rd) |
|
Luke Simmons, 3B (3rd) |
| 2003 |
Andy Schutzenhofer, 1B (1st) |
|
Eric Eymann, SS (2nd) |
|
Joe Ziemba, P (3rd) |
| 2004 |
Chris Robinson, C (1st) |
|
Chad Frk, 3B (3rd) |
|
Tim Gorski, P (3rd) |
| 2005 |
Dusty Bensko, 1B (1st) |
|
Drew Davidson, OF (1st) |
|
Ryan Rogwski, OF (1st) |
|
Chris Robinson, C (1st) |
|
Brian Blomquist, P (1st) |
|
J.R. Kyes, 2B (2nd) |
|
Mike Rohde, DH (2nd) |
|
Jimmy Conroy, P (2nd) |
| 2006 |
Ryan Snowden, OF (2nd) |
|
Ryan Hastings, 2B (3rd) |
|
Shawn Roof, SS (3rd) |
| 2007 |
Lars Davis, C (1st) |
|
Tanner Roark, P (2nd) |
|
Daniel Webb, DH (3rd) |
| 2008 |
Kyle Hudson, OF (1st) |
|
Joe Bonadonna, 2B (2nd) |
|
Daniel Webb, DH (2nd) |
|
Brandon Wikoff, SS (2nd) |
|
Kevin Manson, SP (3rd) |
| 2009 |
Dominic Altobelli, 3B (1st) |
|
Brandon Wikoff, SS (1st) |
|
Pete Cappetta, OF (2nd) |
|
Willie Argo, OF (3rd) |
|
Aaron Johnson, C (3rd) |
|
Will Strack, SP (3rd) |
| 2010 |
Josh Parr, SS (3rd) |
| 2011 |
Pete Cappetta, 2B (2nd) |
|
Adam Davis, C (2nd) |
|
Josh Parr, SS (2nd) |
|
Willie Argo, OF (3rd) |
|
Wes Braun, RP (3rd) |
|
Casey McMurray, OF (3rd) |
| 2012 |
Willie Argo, OF (1st) |
|
Thomas Lindauer, SS (3rd) |
|
Justin Parr, OF (3rd) |
| 2013 |
David Kerian, 1B (1st) |
|
Thomas Lindauer, SS (1st) |
|
Justin Parr, OF (1st) |
|
Kevin Duchene, SP (2nd) |
|
Jordan Parr, OF (2nd) |
| 2014 |
Jason Goldstein, C (2nd) |
|
Adam Walton, SS (2nd) |
|
Will Krug, OF (2nd) |
|
John Kravetz, SP (2nd) |
|
Tyler Jay, RP (2nd) |
|
Casey Fletcher, OF (3rd) |
| 2015 |
Kevin Duchene, SP (1st) |
|
Casey Fletcher, OF (1st) |
|
Jason Goldstein, C (1st) |
|
Tyler Jay, RP (1st) |
|
David Kerian, 1B (1st) |
|
Adam Walton, SS (1st) |
|
Drasen Johnson, SP (2nd) |
|
John Kravetz, SP (3rd) |
|
Pat McInerney, 1B (3rd) |
|
Ryan Nagle, OF (3rd) |
|
Reid Roper, 2B (3rd) |
| 2016 |
Cody Sedlock, SP (1st) |
|
Jason Goldstein, C (3rd) |
| 2017 |
Jack Yalowitz, OF (1st) |
|
Pat McInerney, 1B (2nd) |
|
Michael Massey, 2B (3rd) |
| 2018 |
Bren Spillane, 1B (1st) |
|
Michael Massey, 2B (2nd) |
|
Ben Troike, SS (2nd) |
|
Joey Gerber, RP (3rd) |
|
Doran Turchin, OF (3rd) |
| 2019 |
Garrett Acton, RP (1st) |
|
Andy Fisher, SP (1st) |
|
Michael Massey, 2B (1st) |
|
Zac Taylor, OF (1st) |
|
Jack Yalowitz, OF (3rd) |
| 2021 |
Justin Janas, DH (1st) |
|
Jackson Raper, 3B (1st) |
|
Branden Comia, SS (3rd) |
|
Ryan Hampe, C (3rd) |
|
Andrew Hoffmann, SP (3rd) |
| 2022 |
Justin Janas, 1B (2nd) |
|
Branden Comia, 3B (2nd) |
|
Cam McDonald, OF (2nd) |
|
Cole Kirschsieper, SP (2nd) |
|
Danny Doligale, OF (3rd) |
| 2023 |
Ryan Moerman, OF (2nd) |
|
Jack Wenninger, SP (2nd) |
| 2024 |
Camden Janik, C (1st) |
|
Jacob Schroeder, DH (1st) |
|
Brody Harding, 2B (2nd) |
|
Ryan Moerman, OF (2nd) |
|
Cameron Chee-Aloy, UTL (3rd) |
|
Drake Westcott, 1B (3rd) |
